This simple but clear graphic shows there are expedients needed to fulfill God’s command to sing. The church has discretion to choose the spiritual words and the tune and even whether to compile the songs to be sung. The expedient is necessary to expedite God’s word to sing. But remember that you
will only be singing the spiritual songs that please God.
Those who love musical instruments enough to divide the church over them have to justify their use by taking on one of two mutually exclusive positions.
First, they can claim their guitar is an expedient to fulfill the command to sing. The heart since it is specified in the New Testament is itself therefore not an expedient, Eph 5:19. But, If the instrument is an expedient, by definition it is not a command. The problem with claiming musical instruments are an expedient is that singing requires no musical instrument. Singing requires numerous expedients, but not a single string, horn, or drum. The organ was added hundreds of years after Jesus started the church. That fact pretty much dismisses the notion of them being an expedient.
Second, they claim that musical instruments are commanded or implied for use in the church. If the instrument is commanded, then by definition it is not an expedient. If the musical instrument is commanded, then like with singing, all Christians would be playing an instrument. Just as everyone sings, prays, gives, partakes of the Lord’s Supper, so a command to pluck strings would apply to all. 
Of course no one ever claims that musical instruments are commanded. Since the church did not use musical instruments for hundreds of years until the Catholic church added them, it proves their use was never commanded.
Since musical instruments are not necessary for singing and since no command has ever been claimed, they are an addition to the Word of God. Adding to God’s word is sin that misty be repented of. The addition of indulgent to Christian worship has proven to divide and make impossible the unity Jesus prayed for, Join 17.
I hope you will worship this week just as God commanded by singing.
I offer this humbly. 

Categories: Uncategorized

4 replies

  1. This is the simplest explanation of expedient vs. addition I have seen. The chart helps a lot. Once our class was discussing singing psalms, hymns and spiritual songs and someone said that to sing Psalms implied that an instrument was acceptable because Psalms were sung with instruments (at least some of them had instructions about instruments). I don’t think there is any suggestion in the NT that instruments are necessary to sing Psalms. Do you have any studies on the Hebrew word that was translated Psalms as in the OT _Book of Psalms_?



  1. EXPEDIENT, COMMAND, OR ADDITION? by Dan Mayfield – A Conquering Faith

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: